Photos by Amber Ford for The Marshall Project. Reporting by Stephanie Casanova for Signal Cleveland.

Alfred Cleveland wants people who watch his play, “The Lynched Among Us,” to be outraged.

Cleveland is a co-founder of Voices of Injustice, a group of men who were wrongfully convicted or are fighting to prove their innocence.  

The play, which amplifies the personal stories of exonerees and wrongful convictions, debuted this month at Cleveland State University College of Law. It includes a blend of personal monologues, raps and skits based on real life events.  

The cast of “The Lynched Among Us” gather in prayer at Comma Club Collections clothing store in Euclid before a rehearsal. The men who participated in the play each served between 15 and 27 years in Ohio prisons. Pictured from from left to right are Charles Jackson, Joseph “Scooter” Atwater, Michael Sutton, Wesley “WallStreet Wes” Robinson. Credit: Amber Ford for The Marshall Project
Michael Sutton, right, rehearses a scene from “The Lynched Among Us” with his castmate, Jerome “Kiko” Chambers, at Comma Club Collections in Euclid. Sutton said his life and freedom depended on appeals documents, which were denied several times. “Every time I got denied, it was like I had to relive that judgment day over again,” Sutton said. “And it was just so much darkness that there wasn’t no light.” Credit: Amber Ford for The Marshall Project
Charles Jackson rehearses a scene from “The Lynched Among Us” with an actor playing a detective at Comma Club Collections in Euclid. The detective tells Jackson that although his story may be true it isn’t good enough to be believable. Credit: Amber Ford for The Marshall Project
Al Cleveland, the writer and director of “The Lynched Among Us” watches actors rehearse a scene at Comma Club Collections in Euclid. The formerly incarcerated actors were doing performing arts while in prison, though in limited ways, Cleveland said. Credit: Amber Ford for The Marshall Project

When they got out of prison, many of the wrongfully convicted men involved with the group leaned on one another for support. Voices of Injustice formed organically from that support system, Cleveland said.

“We said, let’s come together. We’re stronger together. We’re more powerful together,” he said. “And let’s find a way where we can spread our message and tell our stories a little more aggressively.”

The program for “The Lynched Among Us,” sits on a chair in the auditorium of Cleveland State University College of Law. Credit: Amber Ford for The Marshall Project
Audience members wait for the start of “The Lynched Among Us,” a play that amplifies the stories of exonerees and people with wrongful convictions. Credit: Amber Ford for The Marshall Project

“We felt it was our time to just take the steering wheel and do our own representation of wrongful conviction,” Ru-El Sailor told Signal Cleveland. Sailor owns the Comma Club Collections clothing store, where he hosts Voices of Injustice meetings and rehearsals.  

Cleveland, who wrote and directed the play, said he wants audience members to feel called to action. He wants people to vote, especially for judges and local elected leaders who impact the criminal legal system. He wants people to be part of a jury. Cleveland also wants people to get involved in holding police officers and prosecutors accountable when they’re involved in a wrongful conviction. And he wants to raise awareness about wrongful convictions and show people, through these stories, what happens in the criminal legal system. 

For Sailor, the more than 300 people who watched the play earlier this month are already raising awareness. 

“We put 300 conversations out that night,” Sailor said. “That’s how I look at it. Everybody who left there went home and told somebody they went to that play. That’s 600 people guaranteed that night talking about wrongful convictions.” 

Michael Sutton, a member of “The Lynched Among Us” cast, with his daughter Legacy before the play performance. “I used to dream of this little girl when I was in jail,” Sutton said in an interview. “All my dreams came true through God blessing me.” Credit: Amber Ford for The Marshall Project
Audience members watch “The Lynched Among Us” at the Cleveland State University School of Law mock courtroom. Credit: Amber Ford for The Marshall Project
A courtroom scene performed by (left to right) Lori Holmes, Jerome “Kiko” Chambers, Leah Winsberg and Michael Sutton during “The Lynched Among Us” show. Kiko, playing a prosecutor, rapped his dialogue. Credit: Amber Ford for The Marshall Project
Charles Jackson, right, with his nephew, Houston. After his release from prison, Jackson donated a kidney to his nephew, who was going through dialysis. “They thought I was a murderer,” Jackson said as he rehearsed his part of the play. “I saved somebody’s life.” Credit: Amber Ford for The Marshall Project

Ultimately, the men want their stories to lead to an end to wrongful convictions.

“My goal in all this is just to help other brothers that are either going through what I went through or prevent other people from going through what I went through,” said Sailor, who was accused of a shooting served more than 15 years before he was released in 2018.

On Nov. 4, the group will perform the play at Warrensville Heights High School. Students will watch a PG-13 version of the play during the school day and parents and other community members can watch the play at 6 p.m. Tickets are on sale on Eventbrite. 

Cleveland wants the play to serve as a cautionary tale for students so they can avoid putting themselves in a situation where they may end up incarcerated, he said. 

Voices of Injustice members are also slated to perform the play in Columbus at the Lincoln Theater in February.

Signal background

The Justice System

The Marshall Project is a nonpartisan, nonprofit news organization that seeks to create and sustain a sense of national urgency about the U.S. criminal justice system. Through a partnership with Signal Cleveland, The Marshall Project is weaving more resident voices into its reporting and building an understanding about how the justice system works — and doesn’t work — in Cleveland.